Negative Reinforcements Shape Behaviours To Fight And Flight…
Carl Jung, another brilliant Psychologist said – “People will do anything, no matter how absurd, to avoid facing their own souls.” That’s some powerful words.
This is a quote from B.F Skinner “About Behaviourism”.
Punishment is easily confused with negative reinforcement, sometimes called “aversive control.” The same stimuli are used, and negative reinforcement might be defined as the punishment of not behaving, but punishment is designed to remove behavior from a repertoire, whereas negative reinforcement generates behavior.
My very existence at the moment is a huge Negative Reinforcement to many dog trainers out there – and to some dog owners. That isn’t something I need to put any effort into – it’s just reality. When my face shows up on camera – certain peoples cortisol and adrenaline levels increase – and they can’t help how they behave.
The result from this increase in hormones causes these people to “fight and/or flight”. And that only comes from something you deem negative in the environment – something you are scared of and trying to chase away – or run away from.
The dark side of Positive Reinforcement is what you are willing to do in defense of self – in the face of self salvation – your desire not to die or be harmed. Jungian psychology would call that ‘the shadow’. Think about that long and hard. Your fight or flight response – is your Positive Reinforcement.
A huge chunk of your Positive Reinforcement is your fight or fight response – you’re trying to remove Negative Reinforcements – or to remove yourself from a Negative Reinfocement. It’s no different for the dog.
If you’re scared of spiders – then spiders are a natural negative reinforcement to you – the spiders very existence is punishing you in a sense – removing your Positive Reinforcement – interrupting your state of calm. My very existence is punishing certain people.
I am a threat to them. The question has to be why. Why is my message such a threat to their existence? Or is it Skinner himself that is the very threat?
When you see a spider – your body is going to go into fight and/or flight – that’s reality. You either “fight” – kill the spider or throw it outdoors – that’s your Positive Reinforcement – you’re removing the negative reinforcement to get back to Positive – or a calm state.
Or you can “flight” – run away from it, jump on a chair and hope that it goes away. You are avoiding/escaping that Negative Reinforcement – removing yourself from the Negative Reinforcement. That’s also your Positive Reinforcement.
My very existence is a Negative Reinforcement to many people – trainers and owners alike. I can’t help that. But I do enjoy their fight and flight response. What is that fight response?
They look for anything negative – and they focus on anything negative. That’s all they can do. One of my videos can be 99% positive – but they ignore all that – and they bring anything negative to the forefront. And that one percent negative trumps everything.
I stand by everything I say. I mean what I say. You can twist it in any way you want to. Just because you can’t or won’t even attempt to understand it – is not my concern. Negative or positive attention – I’ll take it all.
And all I can say is thank you. I love when pure ignorance reacts to my videos.
Robert, conflating punishment with negative reinforcement is a common pitfall, but it oversimplifies the complexity of human (and canine) behavior. Negative reinforcement is about the removal of an unpleasant stimulus to encourage a behavior, while punishment aims to extinguish it. Just because your very presence induces a stress response in some doesn’t mean you’re some kind of natural disaster in their life; it means they may have unresolved issues that need addressing. That’s on them —like trying to blame a rainstorm for someone’s bad hair day.